I know a FromSoftware game is going to be good when my first reaction to it is anger, frustration, and utter despair. I've had an adverse reaction to the start of every Dark Souls, Elden Ring, and Demon's Souls, proclaiming to anyone who'd listen that I'd never touch any of these games again, only to then put hundreds of hours into them. I'm nothing if not consistent. 😀

elden-ring-nightreign-s-forsaken-hollows-dlc-is-brutally-hard-and-i-love-it-image-0

Elden Ring Nightreign was no different. Dropped into the chaos that is Limveld, I had no idea what was going on or why I had just spawned next to one of the Godskin duo at an evergaol. It was a rough entry into the game, and I hated it. Then I played another round and started to join the dots together. Snap to 200 hours later, and I had beaten all the Nightlords and their Everdark variants. But games were strangely easy. πŸ’€

Well, FromSoft must've heard all my bragging. The latest DLC, Forsaken Hollows, launched last week, and it's rough. I've been repeatedly stomped on by the two new nightlords, the Balancers and Dreglord, whether I'm playing one of the new nightfarers or not. I can't even get past the second night boss sometimes. Why is that Demon Prince so angry? And who thought it was a good idea to let Curseblade and Divine Beast Warrior team up? πŸ”₯

elden-ring-nightreign-s-forsaken-hollows-dlc-is-brutally-hard-and-i-love-it-image-1

But the difficulty of the latest DLC hasn't stopped a shedload of dedicated nightfarers from diving in and putting themselves through the wringer. '2 million nightfarers in search of the Forsaken Hollows,' an official blog post says. 'For every nightfarer who joined the hunt against the Dreglord, we offer our immense gratitude.' That's a lot of Tarnished-adjacent masochists. πŸ˜…

elden-ring-nightreign-s-forsaken-hollows-dlc-is-brutally-hard-and-i-love-it-image-2

I don't want to speak for everyone playing this DLC, as not everyone welcomed the update with open arms. But while I initially bounced off Forsaken Hollows as I do with every FromSoftware game, I've come to love it for its difficulty. The new map is only just starting to click as I learn where I can and cannot go, what's the best order to go about exploring the map, and which points of interest are actually worth my time. Starting again from scratch has actually been really rewarding. πŸ—ΊοΈ

Here's a quick breakdown of what's making the DLC so punishing:

New content Why it hurts
Balancers (new nightlord) Relentless pressure that punishes greedy swings
Dreglord (new nightlord) A hunt that demands patience and route planning
New nightfarers Fresh kits, but no easy carry through the new map
Remixed bosses Demon Prince, Curseblade, and Divine Beast Warrior team-ups
New map Fewer safe routes and more punishing points of interest

elden-ring-nightreign-s-forsaken-hollows-dlc-is-brutally-hard-and-i-love-it-image-3

It's no longer a guarantee that I'll hit level 15 before I reach the nightlord, or that I'll even make it past the first or second night boss. There's no more floating through fightsβ€”you need to make every hit count. That's a shock to the system after 200 hours of feeling like I'd solved the base game. But it's also exactly the kind of wake-up call I want from a FromSoft DLC. The DLC doesn't care about your muscle memory from the base game. 😀

There's no telling how long this will actually last, though. Like with the base game, all it takes to master FromSoft games is some dedication, grit, and practice. Players will likely turn getting through the new map and bosses into an art form very soon. I'm just going to embrace the chaos until that happens for me. πŸ’€

If you're diving into Forsaken Hollows, here's what I've learned so far:

  • Expect to die early and often. The new nightlords are not here to be nice. πŸ’€

  • Plan your route. The new map punishes aimless wandering. πŸ—ΊοΈ

  • Don't assume you'll hit level 15 before the nightlord. Adapt. βš”οΈ

  • Every hit counts. Greed will get you killed. πŸ”₯

  • Enjoy the chaos. It's more fun than it sounds. πŸ˜…

elden-ring-nightreign-s-forsaken-hollows-dlc-is-brutally-hard-and-i-love-it-image-4

So yes, I've been repeatedly stomped on. Yes, I've questioned why I do this to myself. But I've also come to love Forsaken Hollows for the same reason I love every FromSoftware game: it makes me earn every victory. And right now, with 2 million other nightfarers hunting the Dreglord, I know I'm not alone in the suffering. 😀πŸ”₯